The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast – 378. Posie Parker: Anti-Trans Activist or Women’s Rights Champion? | Kellie-Jay Keen

Intro

In this episode of “The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast,” Jordan Peterson interviews Kelly J. Keane, also known as Posey Parker, a women’s rights activist. They discuss the invasion of women’s spaces by the transgender movement, the importance of women’s exclusive spaces, and the dangers of false compassion and ideological control of speech.

Main Takeaways

Women’s Rights and Transgender Activism

• Kelly J. Keane, also known as Posey Parker, is a women’s rights activist.
• The transgender movement is invading women’s spaces and co-opting women’s rights activism.
• False compassion is being used to censor and control speech.
• Posey Parker aims to give women a platform to speak through her events.
• Social pressure, ideologically captured police, and terrorizing mobs have not silenced her.

Defining Womanhood and Women’s Rights

• In 2018, Posey Parker put up a billboard with the dictionary definition of a woman as “adult human female.”
• Received hate and vitriol for asking a man in a woman’s forum if he identified as a woman.
• Women compete in giving away women’s rights to gain currency as “nice people.”
• Anti-social behavior among women documented in psychiatric research, using gossip and malicious slander.
• The sin of Eve in the story of the Garden of Eden was pride, leading to the fall.

Challenges of the Left and Women’s Fears

• The speaker questions when the left goes too far and believes that pushing for equity is a complete disaster.
• The Democrats the speaker has spoken to have never been able to answer when the left goes too far.
• The speaker believes that the left has a dismissive attitude towards women and their fears and that there is a disregard for truth in favor of ideologies and power.
• The speaker does not believe that the left is less misogynistic than the right, citing the trade union movements in the UK as an example.
• The speaker questions whether the left has always been like this or if they have dramatically changed.

Personal Experiences and Parenting

• The speaker worked for a leftist political party in Canada when she was young and found many of the leaders admirable, but eventually left due to the behavior of the activists.
• The speaker believes that compassion is the best camouflage for narcissistic individuals and that the left’s claims of compassion have allowed narcissists to invade and dominate the movement.
• The inability of liberal types on the left to draw boundaries is potentially fatal for the movement.
• The speaker struggles with self-definition as an anti-transgender rights activist and identifies as an adult human female, mother, wife, and subject of the law.
• The left needs to be careful not to be invaded by real predators who use claims of compassion to gain power.

Women’s Exclusive Spaces and Gender Identity

• Women’s rights activist believes that women should have exclusive spaces.
• Equality Act is being debated in terms of defining sex and allowing for women-only spaces.
• Proportionate means should justify women-only spaces without needing to justify excluding trans women.
• Legal fiction of trans women is preposterous and leads to issues in women’s spaces.
• Trans activism is a form of cultural appropriation and can be driven by psychopathology.

Summary

Women’s Rights, Transgender Activism, and False Compassion

Kelly J. Keane, also known as Posey Parker, is a women’s rights activist who raises concerns about the invasion of women’s spaces by the transgender movement. She believes that false compassion is being used to censor and control speech, and aims to provide a platform for women to speak out through her events. Despite facing social pressure, ideologically captured police, and terrorizing mobs, Posey Parker continues to advocate for women’s rights.

Defining Womanhood and Women’s Rights

Posey Parker sparked controversy by putting up a billboard with the dictionary definition of a woman as an “adult human female.” She faced hate and vitriol for questioning a man’s presence in a woman’s forum. Posey highlights the competition among women to give away women’s rights in order to gain social currency. She also refers to psychiatric research documenting anti-social behavior among women, including gossip and malicious slander. Posey draws parallels between the sin of Eve in the Garden of Eden and the potential pitfalls of women’s claims to all-encompassing care and status.

Challenges of the Left and Women’s Fears

Posey questions when the left goes too far and criticizes the dismissive attitude towards women’s fears. She believes that the left prioritizes ideologies and power over truth and disregards women’s concerns. Posey argues that the left is not necessarily less misogynistic than the right, citing examples from trade union movements in the UK. She reflects on whether the left has always been this way or if there has been a significant change.

Personal Experiences and Parenting

Posey shares her personal experiences working for a leftist political party in Canada and witnessing the behavior of activists that eventually led her to leave. She argues that compassion can be a camouflage for narcissistic individuals, and warns against the left being invaded by such predators. Posey struggles with self-definition as an anti-transgender rights activist and emphasizes her identity as an adult human female, mother, wife, and subject of the law. She highlights the importance of setting boundaries and not allowing false compassion to dominate the movement.

Women’s Exclusive Spaces and Gender Identity

Posey advocates for women’s exclusive spaces and raises concerns about the Equality Act’s impact on defining sex and allowing for women-only spaces. She argues that proportionate means should justify women-only spaces without needing to justify excluding trans women. Posey criticizes the legal fiction of trans women and highlights the potential issues it creates in women’s spaces. She views trans activism as a form of cultural appropriation and suggests it may be driven by psychopathology.

Conclusion

Posey Parker’s interview with Jordan Peterson sheds light on the challenges faced by women’s rights activists in the face of transgender activism. She emphasizes the importance of women’s exclusive spaces, the dangers of false compassion, and the need for boundaries in political movements. Posey’s personal experiences and insights provide valuable perspectives on the current state of the left, women’s rights, and gender identity debates.